Special Offer* - We'll Beat Any Genuine Written Quote by 10%. Limited Time. Contact Us Now!

When you picture the home of your dreams, chances are you’re thinking about aesthetics alone. The kitchen layout, the garden, or maybe the bathroom finishes. But here’s a little secret: one of the biggest decisions new homeowners make is regarding the roof.

What material is best for Adelaide? How to increase the roof’s lifespan in Adelaide? And what adds value?

The questions keep piling up. But we’re here with the ultimate tile vs metal roofing comparison that’ll ease your nerves for good.

The Case for Tile Roofing

Adelaide’s streetscape is incomplete without its classic tile roofs. Let’s look at the pros and cons of tiles to make your decision easier.

The Pros of Tile Roofing

  • A traditional look, suits older homes
  • Good insulation against heat/noise
  • Long track record in Adelaide’s suburbs

Cons of Tile Roofing:

  • Heavier weight puts strain on older structures
  • Tiles may get damaged more often
  • Moss and lichen growth are common
  • Repairs add up
  • Roof restorations don’t last as long as metal’s

The Case for Metal Roofing

Modern metal roofing (such as Colorbond®) has become the go-to choice for new builds. It’s also a popular material for roof replacement in Adelaide.

Pros of Metal Roofing

  • Lightweight yet incredibly durable
  • Built to withstand local conditions (rust, corrosion, bushfire, etc.)
  • Huge range of colour options
  • Provides better insulation
  • Stays good as new for decades

Cons of Metal Roofing

  • Slightly higher upfront cost
  • Older myths (like noise or rust) still linger
  • Potential for denting in extreme weather

Key Considerations When Choosing Between Tile and Metal

Deciding between tile vs metal roof isn’t only about the material. A few extra factors can help guide the smartest decision for your Adelaide home.

Location and Climate

Coastal suburbs like Glenelg or Semaphore face salty air. This speeds up wear on older tiles and untreated metal. In these areas, modern metal roofing is the safer option.

The Structure’s Age

Tiles are heavy, and older homes may struggle under the weight. Ageing is a more relevant factor if you’re switching tiles to a metal roof later on.

Budget Factor 

A tile restoration is cheaper upfront and lasts 7 to 10 years. Metal roofing costs more at installation but pays off with decades of durability. It’s a tradeoff, mostly decided by the available budget.

Aesthetics and Street Appeal

This is more about personal preference. Are you looking for a classic look? Or, you want an advanced, weatherproof roof? Answering these will end the debate regarding tile vs metal roofing.

Long-Term Value

If you’re planning to sell soon, a tile restoration might be enough. If this is your forever home, metal roofing will give you more return on investment.

How Roof Renewal SA Can Help

To get the best advice and roof installation, you’ll need a team that knows all options equally well. And not to forget how these materials behave in your suburb’s conditions.

For all these reasons, Roof Renewal SA is the perfect fit to get all kinds of roof services in Adelaide. Reliable, fast, knowledgeable, you name it! We’ve got all the qualities to fix roofs better than any other local business.

Ready to Make the Smart Roofing Choice for Your Home?

Choosing the right team is as important as deciding between tile and metal roofing. In fact, an expert team will help choose the best option based on experience. That’s what we’ve been doing for 15 years: enabling smart choices and best results.

  • Quality materials
  • Workmanship guarantee
  • Free quote upfront
  • Residential, commercial expertise
  • Area knowledge

Call 0433 249 417 to begin your hassle-free roofing upgrade. Your home’s safety depends on it.

Metal roofing has come a long way over the years. But the myths? They’ve stuck around. From noise complaints to rust fears, we’ve heard it all. And if you’ve been putting off a roof replacement because ‘metal roofs aren’t worth it’, this one’s for you.

Let’s debunk some of the biggest misconceptions we hear from Adelaide homeowners. This blog post is all you need to make a confident call about your next roof.

1. Metal Roofs Are Too Noisy in the Rain

This one’s a classic and totally outdated. Yes, if you nailed a sheet of tin directly onto a timber frame with nothing underneath, you’d hear every drop. But that’s not how modern metal roofing works.

Today’s installations include:

  • Proper insulation
  • Sarking
  • Ceiling cavities
  • Secure fixing systems 

All of that acts as a sound barrier, absorbing and softening rain impact. In fact, many homeowners are surprised at how quiet their new metal roof is.

Bottom line? A properly installed metal roof isn’t noisy. It’s just well-prepared for Adelaide storms.

2. Metal Roofs Rust Easily

We get this one a lot. And it makes sense coming from people living near the coast. But the truth is, high-quality metal roofing like Colorbond and Zincalume is specifically engineered to resist corrosion. These materials are coated with a mix of zinc, aluminium, and protective paint designed to withstand Australia’s harshest conditions.

Rust usually appears on older roofs that were never treated properly. If your current roof is already corroding, that’s more a sign of age than a flaw in the concept.

3. Metal Roofing Is Too Expensive

We understand the hesitation. Replacing your roof is a significant investment. But here’s the thing: metal roofing isn’t about the cheapest upfront option. It’s about long-term value.

Metal roofs last decades longer than tile restorations. They’re lower-maintenance, bushfire-safe, and energy-efficient thanks to their reflective properties. And when you compare the cost of repeated tile repairs every few years to one high-quality re-roof, the difference adds up fast.

Adelaide homeowners switching from tile to metal are often surprised by the total savings. Not just in roofing bills, but energy too.

4. You Can’t Walk on a Metal Roof

You can, but leave it to the professionals.

Metal roofs are safe to walk on if you know what you’re doing. Trained roofers understand how to distribute weight across the purlins and avoid damaging panels or fixings. In fact, our team walks metal roofs every day – during inspections, gutter work, and full replacements.

5. Metal Roofs Look Too Industrial

Not anymore.

Modern metal roofing comes in dozens of colours and profiles to suit everything from minimalist homes to heritage bungalows. At Roof Renewal SA, we use Colorbond’s full range, which includes soft greys, classic reds, deep greens, and coastal tones.

We’ve replaced roofs on stone villas in Norwood, beach homes in Brighton, and modern builds in Mount Barker. No two looked the same, but every one had a finish that elevated the home’s street appeal.

Here’s What We Do at Roof Renewal SA

If you’ve been living with a rusted, leaking, or outdated roof (metal or tile) we’re here to help. Most of our customers come to us asking for roof repairs, and we always give them honest options.

Got a tile roof? We can restore it… or help you upgrade to a long-lasting metal replacement.

Or, got a metal roof? We’ll repair it where possible. But if the damage is widespread, re-roofing is the smarter move.

We also replace gutters and downpipes as part of any full roof job, because a new roof is only as good as its drainage. Our team handles everything from inspection to restoration with fast turnaround, and the best quality guaranteed.

Don’t Let Old Myths Hold Back Your Roof Upgrade

Still picturing a rusty, loud, industrial-looking roof from the ’80s? That’s not today’s metal roofing. Today’s systems are sleek, strong, quiet, and built for decades of performance. If you’ve got questions or want to explore your options, we’re just a call away. Get solid advice from Adelaide’s local metal roofing experts today.

Metal roofs are renowned for their sturdiness and are designed to outlast most other materials, resist fire, and stand up to Australia’s tough weather. They offer a variety of benefits, including being lightweight, highly energy-efficient, and often reflecting heat, keeping your house cool rather than absorbing it.

However, even the strongest metal roofing systems can have their weaknesses. And fasteners are one of them!

At Roof Renewal SA, our experts have been helping residents and businesses across Adelaide to catch all sorts of roofing problems, be it leaks, breakage, or replacement. Our motto is to be the first to respond and provide solutions that save you the maximum money!

Getting back on track, one of the most common culprits of leaks in metal roofs is loose or rusted screws that quietly let water seep in overtime. Fortunately, most of these problems can be averted with regular checks and a solid understanding of where trouble is usually found. Let’s dive in!

What You’ll Learn in This Blog:
– What causes metal roof screws to become common leak points
– How fastener mistakes, aged washers, and missed framing lead to water damage
– Why UV exposure and weather stress wear down your roof’s sealing
– Simple warning signs to watch for before a leak worsens
– How Roof Renewal SA inspects, maintains, and prevents costly roof issues

What Causes Metal Roof Leaks?

A hidden culprit of metal roof leaks is often installation errors, worn-out rubber washers, missed framing targets, corrosion, or sealant failure. Over the years, UV exposure and temperature changes can also degrade these components, causing water to seep through even the tiniest gaps.

Let’s break down what usually goes wrong in such cases:

1. Fastener Malfunctions

Screws must be installed exactly right. 

  • If they are driven in too hard, the rubber washer beneath gets squashed and can’t do its job.
  • If they are too loose, there’s a gap where water can creep through. 
  • If the screw is at an angle, the washer won’t sit flat, which also weakens the seal. 

These small mistakes are more common than you’d think, especially in DIY or rushed installations.

2. Screws That Miss Their Mark

Every screw should anchor into solid timber or a purlin underneath the roofing sheet. However, we often find screws that are misplaced, as they’re simply sitting in the metal sheet with no support behind them. This means the washer doesn’t compress properly, and without that snug fit, water finds a way in. It’s something we check for during every inspection. 

3. Worn-Out Washers

If you’re someone who has overlooked their roofs for longer than you can think, then there’s a high chance that your rubber washers are beginning to wear out. Especially after years of exposure to the sun and seasonal weather fluctuations, it’s common to find this problem

Be mindful that around the 7 to 12-year mark, rubber washers can crack or brittle, and once that seal is compromised, even the best-placed screw can leak. 

Performing regular checks and replacing washers at the right time can help prevent small leaks.

4. Corrosion and Weather Stress

The metal expands and contracts with the seasons, and that’s exactly why constant movement slowly loosens screws and weakens the watertight seal. 

When dust or moisture accumulates around the screw head, corrosion begins to take hold very quickly. During the course of time, rusted screws can fail completely, leaving visible stains and even holes.

5. Poor Sealing Around Flashings

Sometimes the issue isn’t the screw itself, it is the flashing around it. 

If the sealant around penetrations (such as vents, chimneys, or skylights) is not applied correctly or has worn out, it becomes another weak spot. Combine that with shifting metal, and leaks become almost inevitable. That is why a comprehensive system inspection is always better than just checking for obvious defects.

What to Look For During Routine Roof Checks

You don’t need to get up on the roof to spot early signs of trouble. From ground level or during routine home checks, keep an eye out for:

  • Cracked or missing rubber washers beneath screw heads
  • Rust stains on roofing sheets, walls, or ceilings
  • Pooling water or debris near screw lines
  • Screws that appear uneven, loose, or slightly lifted

If you notice any of these issues, it’s best to have your roof inspected before the next storm rolls in and exacerbates the problem.

Simple Preventive Steps That Make a Big Difference

Most roof issues don’t start with something big; they begin with something small that’s left unnoticed for too long. But a few mindful checks can make all the difference in keeping your home safe, dry, and protected year-round.

  • Replace washers every 7–12 years, especially in high-sun or weather-exposed areas
  • Check that all screws are properly aligned and secured
  • Use the right torque; too tight can split the washer, and too loose weakens it
  • Clear the roof surface regularly of leaves, branches, and debris
  • Reapply flexible sealant around joints, flashings, and penetrations every few years

Final Word

Roofs do a lot of heavy lifting, so they deserve the same care as the rest of the home. These small tasks might seem insignificant, but they prevent water damage, heat loss, and unnecessary stress down the line.

If you’re not sure what condition your roof is in, you’re not alone. That’s exactly why we’re here. At Roof Renewal SA, we take the time to check every screw, seal, and join so you don’t have to worry when the weather rolls in.

Book your roof inspection today. One simple check can save you a lot later.

It usually starts small. A discoloured patch near the gutter or a few flaky bits in the downpipe – on your roof that used to shine. But when it comes to rust on a metal roof, what looks like a cosmetic issue can quietly turn into a structural one.

In Adelaide’s harsh climate, rust isn’t just inevitable, it’s progressive. And by the time it shows up, your roof might already be sending a bigger message: it’s time for re-roofing. Let’s break down how rust weakens your roof and why you should consider re-roofing.

Why Adelaide Roofs Are Prone to Rust

Adelaide has a lot going for it: leafy streets, coastline views, and backyard BBQ weather. But for roofing, the same environment can be unforgiving.

Here’s why rust is so common on metal roofs in South Australia:

  • Coastal air: Suburbs like Glenelg, Semaphore, and Henley Beach are exposed to salty sea breezes. 
  • Extreme temperatures: Our hot summers and chilly winters wear down protective coatings.
  • Ageing infrastructure: Many older Adelaide homes still have roofs installed decades ago, often without modern rust-proof treatments.
  • Blocked gutters and poor drainage: Standing water speeds up the corrosion process.

Even high-quality materials aren’t immune forever. Over time, all metal roofs will face the rust question. The real issue is whether you catch it early enough to avoid major damage.

5 Signs Your Roof Rust Might Be Serious

Not all rust is created equal. Here are a few red flags that tell you it’s time to stop ignoring the orange tint.

  • Brown stains on your ceiling or walls
  • Flakes or bubbles in the roof paint
  • Rust patches near gutters or fasteners
  • Loose screws or warped panels
  • Your roof’s over 20 years old

    If one or more of these sound familiar, it’s worth getting a professional to take a closer look. Sometimes, it’s a small surface fix. Other times? It’s time to re-roof.

    Repair or Re-Roof? Here’s How to Decide

    When the damage keeps spreading or repairs don’t last, replacement starts making more sense. Re-roofing isn’t just about fixing what’s broken. It’s about starting fresh with stronger, safer materials that actually hold up to Adelaide’s climate.

    If you’re calling someone out every year for new patches, it’s probably time to stop the cycle.

    How Roof Renewal SA Can Help

    At Roof Renewal SA, we’ve seen rusted roofs in every condition imaginable. That’s why our re-roofing service starts with a proper inspection. We’ll always tell you honestly if it’s something we can fix, or if a complete re-roof makes more sense.

    • Free assessments with proofs
    • Quick turnaround
    • Licensed and experienced team
    • Material options to suit each client

    Available in all of Adelaide and its suburbs – coastal, hills-based, or somewhere in between.

    Why Re-Roofing Is a Smart Investment in Adelaide

    There’s more to re-roofing than a new layer of metal. Let’s learn what you gain when you choose to re-roof instead of repair.

    New-Generation Materials

    We use Colorbond and Zincalume. These materials are engineered for Australian conditions and come in rust-resistant grades.

    Better Insulation

    Modern roofing systems help regulate indoor temperatures. This is great for lowering your energy bills throughout the year.

    Street Appeal

    A new roof adds to curb value. So, if you’re planning to sell or just want your home to shine, you know what to do.

    Warranties (AKA Peace of Mind)

    No more guessing when the next patch job will fail. Just decades of solid protection.

    Final Thoughts: Don’t Let Rust Win

    Rust doesn’t shout. It starts quietly – hidden under screws or in a shadowed corner of your roof. But left alone, it spreads, corrodes, and threatens your home’s safety.

    If you’ve spotted early signs or your roof hasn’t been checked in years, now’s the time to act. A quick inspection today could safeguard your tomorrow.

    Book your free roof assessment with Roof Renewal SA today. We’ll prepare your roof for anything Adelaide’s weather throws at it.